Government delivers only more confusion and questions, not workers

With the peak in summer harvest upon us, the Federal Government has today unleashed more confusion and headaches for backpackers and employers alike in announced changes to the Working Holiday Maker program.

The NFF Horticulture Council has called on the Government to scrap its plans to introduce caps and ballots to the program, having been unable to justify impacts on regional economies and national food security.

Chair of the Council Paul Burke said today’s changes eroded confidence even further in the Government’s ability to manage migration as a key lever of economic management.

“Employers and backpackers heard Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke clearly state in media interviews after his September address to the Press Club that their Net Overseas Migration number would be achieved without any of the changes announced that day, including to the Working Holiday Maker program,” said Paul Burke.

“They have heard the Minister today say in Cairns the Net Overseas Migration target will still be met with an additional 20,000 visas being issued to backpackers for a third-year in the country on what was announced in September.

“We know migration targets are arbitrary and driven by politics. It increasingly appears the drive to hit those targets is also illusory rather than real.”

Further eroding confidence are claims made by Government that the new settings would deliver more workers than ever before.

“Our numbers suggest instead the program will deliver nearly 700,000 fewer days of specified work in regional Australia compared to what was needed last year,” said Paul Burke.

“We are calling on the Government to release their workings, on the days of work delivered and also on the number of places under the caps for the remainder of this financial year likely left after everyone completing specified work before the end of February has earnt their extension.”

Despite assurances through consultation, the Government is yet to move on any opportunities to make other migration programs more accessible and commercially relevant to offset the impact of WHM program changes.

“There is no viable, commercially relevant and broadly accessible alternative workforce program available to horticulture employers,” said Mr Burke.

“Until one exists, constraining access to Working Holiday Makers risks leaving businesses without a practical way to fill short-term and seasonal workforce gaps.

“Labour shortages will increase business costs, reduce productivity and constrain the supply of Australian-grown fresh food, putting further pressure on household budgets during a cost-of-living crisis.

“The Council will lead a constructive national conversation into the next federal election about the role of migration in horticulture and as an essential pillar our food and national security.

“Our collective objective should be a migration and workforce system that gives employers the workforce options they need, when they need them, so Australian horticulture can remain productive, profitable and globally competitive.

“We invite the Government along with the Opposition and other parties to join us in this conversation, alongside key stakeholders including unions, Pacific Nations, Timor Leste and others.”

About the Horticulture Council

The Council is the recognised peak body for forming policy and advocating on behalf of the national horticulture industry. Established in 2017, it now comprises 19 national commodity and state-based horticulture bodies.

It is a member of the National Farmers’ Federation, free to establish and advance its own policy positions and responses issues impacting the horticulture industry. 

For more information about the Council click ​here​.